“Be liberal in what you accept from others, conservative in what you accept from yourself.” Postel’s Law.
Communication is a lot like an egg toss. If you throw an egg too hard, the greatest receiver in the world will end up with egg on their fingers. A bad catcher can ruin the gentlest floater of a pitch with a vice-like grip. Hopefully you already see where I’m going with this, but in service of tossing this thought-egg more gently…
A hard statement something like “A script must be between 90 and 120 pages.” That’s a rigid thought, rigidly stated, and it pisses people off because no one likes it when jerks are right. The gentler way to say that is, “A script should be as long as it takes to tell a good story, but 90-120 is a safe range (but by no means a dogmatic one).” Hard ideas are softened by qualifiers. Of course this is a happy medium as well. It’s possible to so neuter a phrase with weasel words that it comes out with such a limp-wristed toss that it never gets close enough for anyone to catch it.
A bad listener is like a bad egg catcher. They can take something like my second example, and find a way to be personally insulted by it. These are the guys who post screeds on articles they haven’t read because they have their own axe to grind. By contrast, a good listener is able to hear a dogmatic statement like “a script must be 90-120 pages,” and think something like “obviously there are exceptions, but this person is stating a general rule and giving me a framework for discussion. He could have made it more abstract and thus more accurate, but I’ll bet beginners appreciate his simple and forthright presentation of his idea. I may disagree, but I should respect his intent to communicate.”
Be a good listener. When you hear something you don’t like, imagine that the speaker prefaced it with “In my humble opinion” and added a footnote like, “Obviously there are exceptions to every rule.” NOTE: Perform this key step inside your head, saying stuff like this out loud is not a good way to win friends or influence people.
On the other other hand, I can’t believe I had to write 500 words to explain Postel’s Law! Argh, why can’t people get things faster!!!!! Whyyyyyy???
That’s bad communication. The less rigid way to say it would be “Some people grasp this instinctively. Others take a little time. But we can all do it and we should endeavor to do so (with the usual compliment of disclaimers).”
Writing is communication is writing is communication. Good writers are curious, self-aware, and have an irony and wit and humor that informs their world view and shines in their writing. The best role models in this respect are people who believe the opposite things that you do, and can still write in a way that reaches you (even the staunchest atheists seem to like Stephen Colbert, Fred Rogers, Roger Ebert and Stephen King).
When someone reacts to a simple suggestion on a forum with an acidic, 500-word screed, I wonder how happy they are in their real life and I wonder if their overflow of bile is also present at toxic levels in their scripts.
Thanks for catching what I’m throwing. I’d love it if anyone tossed a comment back my way. I will endeavor to catch it gently.
PS – The cynics out there might question why you’d participate in an egg toss in the first place. This is a valid question.